The university of hong kong faculty of law the common law. Vicarious liability arises when one person is held liable for the tort of another. While there has been controversy and confusion as to whether the law accepts a general regime of vicarious liability of principals for the torts of their agents see p. The paper mainly focuses on the vicarious liability of the state in criminal offences, and also of corporations. He is not liable for the wrongful acts done by others. Introduction it is difficult to imagine how it would be possible for a man to exist in a modem fashion in our fastmoving modem world if he had to do all things alone, without the aid of others. I3 the existence of such a large atypical workforce is likely to throw the doctrine of vicarious liability into crisis. Pdf vicarious liability or liability for the acts of. The thrust of the book is that the law of tort should be abolished, especially as.
Vicarious liability or liability for the acts of others in tort. Also, for this person to held accountable for the act of the other person, it is necessary that there exists any form of relationship between the person who is accused and the other person. The history of vicarious liability and its twin nondelegable duty is venerable. Assesses the rationale for a contract of service to exist for a party to. Under the principle of vicarious liability a master was held liable for the torts of his servant if these were. Vicarious liability in the law of torts, book, 1967. Vicarious liability and the beautiful game liability for. Dec 22, 2019 vicarious liability in domestic relations is an applied concept of secondary liability. Establishing vicarious liability requires three primary criteria to be met. Pdf vicarious liability or liability for the acts of others in tort. Jw neyers, a theory of vicarious liability 2005 43. Vicarious liability in the law of torts ebook, 1967. Vicarious liability versus nondelegable duty 2018 771 cambridge lj 15, at 17. Atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts butterworths.
Atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts or p. Vicarious liability of employers introduction it is trite law in south africa that an employer will be vicariously liable for the negligent act of his or her employeeemployees or agentagents, in the event of the employeeemployees or agentagents acting in a negligent manner during the course of hisher employment. There is no vicarious liability for delicts committed by independent contractors. The cambridge law journal recasting vicarious liability. Keywordscriminal law, intention, responsibility, vicarious liability introduction vicarious liability is a form of a strict, secondary liability that arises under the common. Law of torts butterworths 1967 12, who argues that vicarious liability. In any case, the law has developed, and it is generally accepted that the development of vicarious liability in its modern form is something of a historical accident, 38 s deakin, organisational torts. Agency 2d vol 1 united states 1958 atiyah vicarious liability. So vicarious liability deals with cases where one person is liable for the acts of others.
The supreme court disagreed with the lower courts assessment of the law of vicarious liability and their view that mr skeltons motive was irrelevant. November 19901 vicarious liability and independent contractors a reexamination the context it is the rise in the numbers of the selfemployed which is of greatest significance for tort lawyers because these are workers who, traditionally, fall outside the scope of the doctrine of vicarious liability. It acts as being saving clause for the inferior, who acts for the wrongful order of their superior that ultimately leads to the wrongful act under tort law. Such actions are nevertheless not the exclusive sources. These two maxims have played a significant role in the development of the law of vicarious liability of the master. A member of a conspiracy can be held liable for the crimes committed by another member if the crime was part of the original objective and it was foreseeable for the crime to occur. Tort law has developed over many centuries and has its origins in an agricultural society and largely rural economy of the middle ages in britain. The classic example is that of employer and employee. It was originally authored by english legal scholar, patrick atiyah in 1970 and has been taken over by professor peter cane since the 4th edition in 1987. However, under the law of torts, a person can be held liable for another person.
It represents not a tort, but a rule of responsibility which renders the defendant liable for the torts committed by another. In english law, a corporation can only act through its employees and agents so it is necessary to decide in which circumstances the law of agency or vicarious liability will apply to hold the corporation liable in tort. Mar 22, 2016 vicarious liability, sometimes referred to as imputed liability, is a legal concept that assigns liability to an individual who did not actually cause the harm, but who has a specific superior legal relationship to the person who did cause the harm. Article pdf available in journal of european tort law 21 january 2011 with 8,818. Vicarious liability is a way in which any of the other torts can be attributed to a particular defendant, even if that defendant was not directly involved in the tort. Tort liability act 4121974 chapter 1 scope of application section 1 this act applies to liability for damages. An overview of tort law intentional torts, negligence, and strict liability duration. Useful notes on vicarious liability under indian law. Stretching back to henry ivs reign as regards a masters liability for a servant starting a fire being an example of respondeat superior in contrast to the. By making an innocent party pay compensation for the torts of another, it can also appear unjust. Describe the concept of vicarious liability and explain the rationale forthis concept.
Understanding vicarious liability in criminal law legalmatch. As pointed out by atiyah, the principle of vicarious liability needs to be justified, as holding someone liable for the acts of another is contrary to english law in that people should only be liable if they are at fault. In the field of torts it is considered to be an exception to the general rule that a person is liable for his own acts only. Duties to ensure that care is taken jonathan morgan b engages an independent contractor, c.
It is because an employer is liable for damages caused to the third party by his employee which is called as employers vicarious liability. A greater range of torts may also now trigger vicarious liability, such as acts of on and offpitch violence. Some commentators estimate that between one third and one quarter of all employment relationships are atypical. Vicarious liability definition, meaning, examples, and cases. It dates back to the days when society was divided into two classes, properly described as masters and servants. Find vicarious liability in the law of torts, by p. A critical analysis of the legal history of vicarious. This book is the first comprehensive treatment of the doctrine of vicarious. Following that approach, cases can be decided on a basis which is principled and consistent. Atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts london. American law institute restatement of the law second. It is believed that person merely performing the actus reus on the say of another is not innocent and thus is also made liable for the offence. Secondary liability is technically when torts committed by a tortfeasor are facilitated or assisted by a second party. Atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts london 1967, pp.
Center for innovation in legal education 233,940 views. Generally, a man is liable for his own wrongful acts. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. There must be a relationship of control, a tortious act, and that act must be in the course of employment. The main premise of the article is that the common law should continue to impose vicarious liability because it can coexis t with the current tort law regime that imposes liability for fault. The doctrine of vicarious liability can also be termed as the heart of the common law system of tort. Atiyahs accidents, compensation and the law wikipedia. Pdf vicarious liability or liability for the acts of others. The doctrine of vicarious liability, generally termed liability for the acts of. May 03, 2014 tort law vicarious liability the law simplified. See also patrick atiyah, vicarious liability in the. Heory of vicariou s liability university college cork.
The most common form of vicarious liability is when employers are held liable for the torts of their employees that are committed during the course of employment. We ship law books world wide and stock books and looseleaf works from all major legal publishers. Vicarious liability and independent contractors a re. See also ps atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts butterworths 1967 171. Buy vicarious liability in the law of torts by atiyah, p. Strict, vicarious, and joint liability strict liability strict liability torts, which do not require a finding of intent or negligence, are primarily confined to. Vicarious liability is a word which combined with two elements which are vicarious and liability. Liability for an employees assaults courts within the british commonwealth have demonstrated a persistent reluctance to hold that an employees assault has been com mitted within the course of his employment so as to make his employer vicariously liable for the tort. Atiyah s accidents, compensation and the law 2006 is a legal text, which marked the first of cambridge university presss law in context series.
Define tortious liability, explain its ingredients, distinguish tort from crime and breach of contract. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The situations disclose that a can be liable for the negligence act committed by b against c. A comparative perspective article pdf available in journal of european tort law 21 january 2011 with 8,818 reads. Nov 08, 2014 the essence of vicarious liability in criminal law is that a person may be held liable as the principle offender that is the perpetrator of a crime whose actus reus is physically committed by someone else.
Vicarious liability has a greater reach within both professional and amateur football than previously thought. Though the phrase vicarious liabilit iys often use tdo describ ane y situation in whic onh persoe ins hel d liabl fo damagre e cause by d another it is, o coursef, neither impossibl nor unusuae fol thir s resul tot. T his article proposes a theory of vicarious liability which attempts to explain the central features and limitations of the doctrine. Generally a person who committed wrongful act is liable for that. However, unless otherwise provided in this or another act, this act does not apply to liability for damages under contract or as provided in another act. Vicarious liability in case of masterservant relationship. Chapter 2 liability of the person causing injury or damage section 1. The use and abuse of the doctrine of vicarious liability. Vicarious liability arises by virtue of the relationship between the actual tortfeasor and the person who is made vicariously liable. Yet it is a principle found in all western legal systems, be they civil law or common law. The university of hong kong faculty of law the common.
See also p s atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts butterworths, 1967 3. Atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts 1967, at p. Can a sue b for the harm caused by the contractor assuming that b is himself blameless. Attention is drawn to attention is drawn to the imprecision of the test by atiyah, vicarious liability in the law of torts 1967. Essentials of vicarious liability in masterservant relationship. There are, however, some justifications for the imposition of this tort. The doctrine of vicarious liability predates the creation by the judges of the law of negligence. These essential conditions have to be followed for the vicarious liability of master to arise. The newlyexpanded doctrine has opened up vicarious liability for amateur players, and within grassroots teams. There have been a number of interesting and noteworthy judicial developments in recent months in the context of employers liability, both primary and vicarious. With reference to the case law, explain legal principles of vicarious liability in the malaysian construction industry and discuss the reasons for their application. Atiyah butterworths london wikipedia citation please see wikipedias template documentation for further citation fields that may be required. Vicarious liability is a form of a strict, secondary liability that arises under the common law doctrine of agency, respondeat superior, the responsibility of the superior for the acts of their subordinate or, in a broader sense, the responsibility of any third party that had the right, ability or duty to control the activities of a violator.
The test as to whether a person is an employee or an independent contractor is the. Search for library items search for lists search for. Recasting vicarious liability the cambridge law journal. Atiyah points out the law relating to vicarious liability in torts displays a remark. It is now widely recognized that an employer who authorizes the commission of a tort will instead be directly liable for the relevant conduct of the employee. The issue of vicarious liability can be seen to be unjust in that someone who is not at fault can be held liable. But sometime a person may be liable for the wrongful act of another. There are three theories of vicarious liability in criminal law, and they are as follows. Vicarious liability is something of an anomaly in the law of torts. Vicarious liability of the employer in sexual harassment. Recasting vicarious liability volume 71 issue 3 phillip morgan. Question 2 law 087 vicarious liability in tortquestion.
Reviews case law broadening the scope of vicarious liability to discuss its possible application to the voluntary sector. Bhons, department of law, saveetha school of law, saveetha institute of medical and. Pdf tort law vicarious liability essay mark pummell. So did professor atiyah in his wellknown book vicarious liability in the law of torts 1967, at pages 280284.
1067 746 495 1671 368 841 291 280 976 430 1088 1412 834 1227 875 1146 1004 751 1624 1643 1327 1638 1314 766 678 274 1236 1620 833 1064 1370 431 1413 1060 1344 301 861 216 1103 1383 260 853